Showing posts with label music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label music. Show all posts

Wednesday, 24 March 2010

Dinosaur Jr

You know that you are going into a Dinosaur Jr concert when some lady at the door is handing out earplugs to all of you. On stage, we had not 1 but 2 indie legends, J Mascis and Lou Barlow. This was the classic incarnation of Dinosaur Jr who released “Bug” and “You’re Living All Over Me”, 2 albums which established them as indie rock legends. Their style of rock was plenty of guitar (courtesy of J Mascis) done Neil Young style, on top of lazy drawling vocals. It was called slacker rock (in case you’re wondering, “slacker” is a near synonym for “bochap”), because everything was done in a sloppy way. But make no mistake, J Mascis was – and is – one of the best guitar players around still. I think he’s even better with Neil Young. Their enduring influence on music was to combine the DIY style indie music with impressive amounts of guitar. Sonic Youth once had a song which had plenty of guitar on it, with the working title “J Mascis for President”. Eventually it got renamed “Teenage Riot” and became their most famous song.

Lou Barlow, the bassist was more the sensitive, lo-fi indie type. Most of the songs from the band came from J Mascis. Barlow’s songs were simpler and low key, and in a way he was also influential on the indie scene. After he left Dinosaur Jr, he formed Sebadoh, and had various projects.

Dinosaur was formed somewhere in Massachusetts. Because another band had a claim on the name Dinosaur, they changed their name to Dinosaur Jr. After “Bug”, some friction developed between Barlow and J Mascis. If I remember correctly, J Mascis fired the whole band, and then reformed it, minus Lou Barlow. Lou Barlow then formed Sebadoh. With Sebadoh, he wrote “The Freed Pig”, one of the most sarcastic and bitter songs ever directed at a former bandmate (check out the lyrics).

Dinosaur Jr continued, essentially as a J Mascis solo project. His output was consistent, but the formula was very much the same: a mix of very loud rock music with a dash of country, verse chorus verse, and then an extended guitar solo. (J Mascis is one of the best guitar soloists out there.) As I remember, I hardly listened to Dinosaur Jr for more than 30 mins at a time because I would get bored of it. So in a way the concerts can be a bit trying.

The reformation of the band a few years ago came as a surprise to all concerned except maybe J Mascis. He probably needed his old partner to revitalise him. One of the most pleasant surprises of the last few years is that old indie bands retain much of their mojo when they reform 10 years after they break up, and when they perform as middle aged old farts. Like the Pixies and Mission of Burma before them, their recent form is comparable to their peak. And check out their video which is a very strong message that the band have put their differences behind them.

On this site, you can see a picture of what they looked like in 1988, compared to their post reformation. So it was a little startling to see what J Mascis looked like, post reformation. I always thought of him as a skinny kid with long brunette hair. Now they call him Gandalf.

I suppose it’s always bittersweet when you sit down at a nice place like the Esplanade and listen to the music that you liked as a teenager, reflecting probably that you are now almost twice as old as when you were listening to that music back then. I listened as that angry, noisy, abrasive, joyful noise came out at me. I was sitting at a circle seat, and the band was at just the right amount of loudness for me. It was great. Those guys below, just under the stage, I don’t know how they could take it. J Mascis said that his concerts usually last a little more than an hour, because after that he’s tired. Probably true, for various reasons: 1. He solos on every song. 2. He needs to go before his ears start bleeding and most likely 3. He’s a slacker.

The crowd was oddly passive. There was no moshing below. I suppose maybe the Esplanade is a very well behaved crowd. Equally likely everybody was aping J Mascis who hardly moved (but of course, he’s the guy who has to think of all the solos). Lou Barlow, in contrast, was head banging away all the time. I suppose it’s not really danceable rock, it’s not heavy metal head banging. But very good driving music all the same.

There were a few jokers who invaded the stage. One was chased down by the security guard. The second hugged Lou Barlow before he went off. Shortly after that, the silhouette of a policeman in a peak cap appeared briefly on stage right. Stupid motherfucker, why spoil our fun like that? I suppose Singapore is not Singapore when you take away the anally retentive over-policing. Lou Barlow bitchily asked why we guys are so interested in his socks, and reminded me for a moment that he was after all the author of “The Freed Pig”.

Out of 5 rows on the circle, only one was taken. I suppose everybody else decided to take the seats downstairs because you could get up close with them. No matter, for me it was great to listen to Dinosaur Jr without going deaf. I only wish I brought the binos because I’m too far to see the faces of those three.

Later on comes the dreaded moment when the band makes an obligatory speech about how great Singapore is. I remember that in the Lovano/ Scofield concert they just muttered that it was a “nice place”. Sonic Youth performed at the Harbour Pavillion 14 years ago before it was torn down to make way for Vivo City. Back then, Thurston Moore said, “We’ve always wanted to come to Singapore, so now we’re here”. Well that was inspiring. Lou Barlow said it was an incredible place. Well I suppose for many of them this would be their introduction to the Far East (of course Australia does not count as the “Far East”). I think this is the first time you’re face to face with so many English-speaking Easterners in the same room so just enjoy it, white boy.

There was some hack yelling out for “Show Me The Way”, whereupon J Mascis strummed the first 4 chords and started playing another song, as if to say “I heard you, but I’m not complying”. Good old J Mascis.

Dinosaur Jr is as sloppy with naming their songs as they are with their singing. So I don’t know their song titles very well. Below are some songs I think they performed.

Songs: Lung, Raisans, Just Like Heaven, Get Me, Back To Your Heart.

Edit: I saw the article about them in the todayonline blog. It’s true that there are quite a few youngsters who are curious about them and turn up. But most of the people in there are about my age group, people who enjoyed their music when they were teenagers. Well in a large way, alternative music is for teenagers, no matter how much more sophisticated and “mature” it is compared to mainstream music.

You don’t have to guess the setlist anymore. It’s up there on the blog.

One irony was that a lot of people in front of Lou Barlow were complaining to him that they couldn’t hear the vocals. He replied, that’s because the guitars are coming out of the Marshall stacks on stage and the vocals are coming out of the PA at the back. That means if I were to have been one of those crowding around the stage, I would have missed out on the vocals, whereas sitting where I was at that time, I got probably the best sound. A shame about being so far away from the stage that you can’t see the band.

Sunday, 28 February 2010

Humpback Oak

A few weeks ago I heard that Humpback Oak were releasing a limited edition boxed set. That was interesting.

Humpback Oak was one of Singapore’s best loved bands. They came up at a time when Singapore did not have much of a local music scene to talk of. (Actually things are a little better now but still not much. Not in English pop anyway.) There were other bands that were being bandied around like the Oddfellows. I had heard of Opposition Party, but they were metal and I didn’t dig metal.

I had heard of Humpback Oak. It was an interesting name, but they were a lot of bands with strange names. (Astreal? Livonia? Padres?) They were bandied around as one of the best Singapore bands. But it’s relative, I thought. Anything half decent would be considered excellent by our standards.

One day when I was in Tower Records (still remember that place?) I heard “Pained Stained Morning” being played. It was good stuff and I liked it. I’m not going to say they are the best band in the world, but it was streets ahead of what I was accustomed to. Funnily enough once I heard it I knew it had to be Humpback Oak, because of the accent, and because the music matched how it was described in the press. Somber, brooding, haunting. The last adjective is most salient because their second album would be called “Ghostfather”.

I got the album afterwards. I liked it, it was good. Musically they are really not very impressive, but Leslie Low was a good songwriter. I was a little startled at how many good tunes there were on that record.

Second album, “Ghostfather” was equally good. Even though it had fewer obvious pop gems than “Pained Stained Morning”, it was a more unified album, dealing with loss, restlessness and anomie. It’s probably one of the gloomiest albums that I’ve heard, in any case.

I don’t know why Leslie Low picked the name Humpback Oak. They are large, heavy objects. Probably archaic as well. I think Humpback Oak’s music is very Singaporean, rooted in the Singaporean experience. They may have been compared to American Music Club and REM, they may have started out playing a lot of Bob Dylan. But there was the heaviness, the feeling of being constantly trapped in a comfortable cage, of being a frog in a well. It’s not a surprise that they were on the soundtrack of Eric Khoo’s “12 Storeys”, which deals with similar themes. They are distinctly un-American. Their music is whatever the opposite of “yes we can” is.

Except that in the sense that your polar opposite is your own mirror, there was a lot to borrow from those American bands which chose to highlight the emptiness and futility of the American dream. You could borrow that, and it would sound right at home over here, and I think that is what Humpback Oak have done.

Lyrics, I wouldn’t have much to say about the lyrics. I think they are Leslie Low’s weak point, even though you still roughly get what his music is all about. Every Humpback Oak album has their fair share of clunkers, like “don’t die, don’t kill yourself, it takes too much time”. Or “Turkey you turkey me”.

But there’s a lot that Singaporeans can identify with. Like not having an identity, and not fully knowing what is the meaning of that flag you sing the national anthem to every morning. Like being alienated from your parents who knew so much more hardship than you did. Like the eerie emptiness of a void deck in the afternoon. Like staring 20 storeys down from the back of your HDB flat, feeling smothered and yearning for release. Because unlike most of the bands out there, Humpback Oak lives in HDB flats too. (Caveat: a lot of black music from the UK comes from council housing, which is rather similar to our HDB, except that their version of the HDB is more seedy.)

The third album, “SideASideB” wasn’t as good as the first 2. But if I listened to it, I could have 1 or 2 of those songs growing on me.

Anyway I made my way to Club Street with a bit of trepidation – I was on ICT and I was expecting a recall on that day. So I had to drive my van and all that army stuff down to my office, park it there, and take a bus to Club Street amid all that messy MRT construction.

I should go back a few steps to explain: Humpback Oak were releasing a boxed set of all their works, containing their 3 CDs, as well as a 4th CD, containing some rarities and (this is the most interesting part) MP3s of all their cassette demos that they used to hawk in indie music shops from when they were struggling musicians. They were going to sell the boxed set exclusively on Saturday and Sunday from 1 to 5 pm, at Polymath & Crust / Books Actually.

So when I got there the queue was snaking down to the first floor. It was a little past 1. The queue went all the way up to the 3rd floor. I bumped into the drummer from the second band. I bumped into Siew Kum Hong. So now you know that the NMP who advocated repealing 377A is also a Humpback Oak fan.
When it was my turn, I wondered whether I should buy 1 or 2. I bought 2, cynically thinking that I could probably sell the second one at an extortionate rate in 5 years’ time, especially since it was autographed by all 4 of them.

So there was this table with Leslie Low and 3 others. They looked like they have aged, they’re no longer the skinny indie kids you saw in the publicity photos. They look bulky and middle aged. I didn’t know which of them was who. I know what Leslie looked like, but today he was different, wearing a goatee and a moustache, and looking like that mask people wore in “V for Vendetta”.

Very hastily I mentioned to one of them that I was thinking of covering one of their songs. Which one? “Home”. Hey Leslie, this guy wants to cover our song. “Really? That’s interesting”, said Leslie. Well just send us a copy when you’re done with it, OK? So, great. Now I owe Humpback Oak a cover version of “Home”.

It’s true, though, that I thought I was going to radically re-invent that song into something trip hop and drum + bass. But I’m a long long way from completing it. I’m even a long long way from figuring out how to do drum + bass. I hear it in my head, though, and surely that counts for something.

Anyway, so I’m the new proud owner of Oaksongs, serial numbers 58 and 59 out of 500. I dunno if they’ve sold out by now. Maybe and maybe not. The obvious first thing is that they have spent a great amount of effort on the packaging. I think it was designed by one of the more famous designers in Singapore. The outside is designed to look like a worn cardboard box. A bit tricky when the cardboard is new. When you open it, it looks like a house inside, an indie slacker’s room with all those concert posters and stuff. There’s a little cardboard bed, which is actually a small box containing teeny weeny booklets with all their lyrics.

Leslie Low went through a lot of trouble making digital photographs of his lyric sheets. (Which I think is strange because lyrics is the one aspect of Humpback Oak that I’m not a fan of.) But you can see some of his old songs scribbled on SJI stationery (all 4 met at and were from SJI). In one of the lyrics, you can see his 6th form poetry and his “O” levels schedule side by side.

I also have to comprang about the CD packaging. The CDs are wrapped up in paper that is origami folded. Obviously not meant for heavy usage. I had to dig out some plastic jewel boxes to put the CDs into.

Otherwise, you can imagine, I was proud of my newest purchase. Now to list my old Humpback Oak albums on eBay and get my $60 back.

As for the recall, you can see from the news: some ppl from the Police and from Civil Defence got recalled, but not the SAF. So I didn't get recalled.

Saturday, 13 February 2010

Songwriting

Another song popped into my head. It wasn't fantastic or anything. But I thought, what the hell, write it down. One day, you're going to be old, and you're going to be glad to be even writing stuff of that standard. Don't be fussy. Build up a stockpile so that you won't regret it when you grow old.

I don’t really know whether or not to write this. I think I may have grown as a songwriter over the last 2-3 years, or maybe I have not. It’s not a coincidence that many people write their best songs before they’re 30. Songwriting is a process, whereby the best ideas, and also the ones that come most naturally to you, are the ones which get written first. So even if you do get better at it as time goes on, your best ideas are already out there, and you simply have to do something different.

Anyway, I’ll put a header on some of my points.

1. Songwriting is a black art.
When people say they write songs, the reaction is naturally scepticism. Why? Because the number of good songwriters out there is comparatively few. It is difficult. Like Bjork says on “Human Behaviour”: There is no map and a compass won’t do. Music theory teaches you relatively little, or at least it’s only half of the story. Music theory is like grammar. Just because you have mastered grammar, it doesn’t make you a great story teller.

2. Music theory.
Of course, having a music education helps. I have been educated in music almost all my life, and I cannot imagine what it is like to listen to music with an uneducated ear, so I take for granted that you will be able to identify notes when hearing them, you will identify chords.

3. Have an opinion.
The second task of a songwriter is to develop taste. Have an opinion about music. Every song, you like it or you don’t like it. Why does this speak to you? What is it saying? Why do some songs remain in the memory, and why do others fade? Why is this something you want to listen to over and over again, and why is that something that irritates you?

This is very important, almost the first skill you have to learn as a songwriter, because you will be using this skill to assess your own work.

I have learnt as much about music from music critics, as I have from my music teachers. I have read reviews about albums, and often wondered, why some albums get bad reviews and others get good ones. Sometimes, music critics are wrong. More often than that, though, they are right. And 20 years later, the critical opinion about a given piece of music should be secure.

4. Emotional vocabulary
Every chord is a colour. (Actually, some people think that every note is a colour too.) But chords are more important than which key of the scale you are playing. Irving Berlin only knew how to write music in the key of F. It doesn’t really matter.

Every chord, relative to the tonic, conveys an emotion. Understand the emotional impact of chords. Simplistically, major chords are happy and minor chords are sad. But not always. From I to IV is like going to a higher plane, and from I to V is going to a lower one. But not always. Inversions (ie changing which note of the chord is used in the bass) change the way the chords sound, and change the emotional shade.

More interesting than the I, IV and V are the relatives of these chords. Sometimes you will have the minor versions, the major versions, the extended chord, your 7s, 9s, 11s, even 13s. Augmented. Diminished. Suspended. Know your chords. This is important.

5. Chord progression
Chord progressions and melody in music are similar to plot and narrative in a story. Like a good maths proof (it is not a coincidence that I learnt how to write a song around the same time I was learning how to write a maths proof) a chord progression is a sequence of ideas which lead, logically to each other. Whether the chord progression makes sense or not, is analogous to whether it is grammatical.

6. Melody
A melody will typically contain certain notes that make up the chord. There will be transitional notes that don’t have much to do with that chord, and they are called passing notes. The melody needs to both be consistent with what’s going on in the chord progression, and at the same time it should be artistically appealing. That’s why writing a song is not easy – it’s like solving a simultaneous equation. You don’t want to have a melody which follows the chord progression like a slave. There’s no tension, and it’s boring. But you don’t want to have a melody that is not related to the chord progression either.

Somebody asked “what is melody” in a music forum. It is a very good question. Our most conventional notion of melody is that it is the part of music which is in the foreground, it is typically linear, with only 1 note at a time (like if 1 person is singing). It is a sequence of notes.

Any of these notions can be violated. The melody can be in the bassline. Counterpoint is what we call it when there are 2 melodies playing against each other at the same time. Harmony is what we call it when 2 or more non-clashing notes are played together. 2 or more voices can make up the same melody, they just sing different parts of it.

7. Form
Almost the first thing people will teach you when you have formal instruction on composition is the form of the music. ABA, AABA, ABABCA, etc. This is important, of course, but it’s like saying that when you write a story, your words must fall on a straight line going from left to right. Although this convention is important, it has very little to do with whether you are writing a good song or not.

There is only 1 thing to learn from the idea of form: big pieces of music are made of smaller pieces of music. How you arrange the smaller pieces is the architecture design.

What’s more important, from my perspective, is how those smaller chunks flow into each other. How everything combines together to form the narrative arc. Always pay attention to the bigger picture, and how the smaller pieces make up the bigger puzzle. Sometimes you can have 2 really spectacular pieces of music, and they sound awful when you put them side by side because the flow is gone. Sometimes you can tolerate having a boring part, because it gives you a break from the exciting part.

8. Hidden melodies
Moving away from our conventional idea of melodies to the bigger picture, we need to understand what is a melody, in a more generic sense. Melodies are narratives. They tell a story. They lead the listener through a series of logically connected moods, and represent an arc through the music for the listener to follow.

If you study the human brain, you will understand that stories are our method of organising information and making sense of them. One favourite technique we have of memorising long lists, is to make up a story where all the items appear in sequence, in the story. The reason why this works is because we are so well adapted to thinking about stories.

Similarly, it is difficult for me to memorise a lot of numbers (musical notes are basically numbers. Sounds inhuman, but deal with it.) But when they are arranged in a catchy melody – miracle of miracles, it’s so easy.

So when you extend the definition of melody, into something like a catchy hook, or a motif, or a drum figure, the definition becomes something like: foreground.

This should explain why hip hop and rap works, even though there are so few chords and melodies. It’s all hidden melodies – the brain still has something to latch onto. Maybe it’s the combination of wordplay, or the rhythm of the words, or catchy slogans.

But the cardinal rule is this: the brain still has to have something to latch onto. Something to think about. Take away chords and melody, maybe you have to make the rhythm interesting. Or maybe you have to make the architecture interesting, like how minimalist music takes away a lot of your points of reference, and instead you pay attention to how the mood shifts and changes very subtly. But music cannot be vacuous.

9. Borrowing ideas
I’m not good enough to come up with my own ideas. Maybe nobody is. I’ve always borrowed from others. It’s like building a nest, all your material is stolen from somewhere else. But the creation, the nest, is yours and yours alone. Unless you steal somebody else’s nest wholesale (or a significant chunk thereof).

So when you are starting to write, just steal. Take a piece here, another piece there, put it together in a way that’s never been done before. Take somebody else’s melody, and harmonise it with different chords. Take somebody else’s chords an put a new melody on it.

Combine genres in a way that has not been done before. Chinese with Indian. Dub with classical. Avant Garde with Gregorian. Whatever.

10. Experience
I started “writing” music when I was 8. I wrote the first song I was happy with when I was 21. Yes, it takes that long. If you start off as an adult, your learning curve will be shorter. But you have to wait a long time and put up with stuff that doesn’t work. Then you learn your lesson from point number 3: assess it like a music critic.

If you can’t finish songs, KIV them. A few songs were stuff I KIV’ed from when I was a teenager, and now I have the experience to complete them, to solve problems I wasn’t able to solve back then.

You might learn some tricks. Like repeating a phrase because it sounds better the second time. Or ending a song abruptly. Or throwing in an unexpected chord.

After a while, the seam that you are mining will be empty. Then branch out, try a different form of music and see what happens. There are a lot of songwriters, they were very good when they were young, and then they lost it. Or rather most of their songs were written and as a consequence they ended up repeating themselves. There wasn't much that was new. Brian Wilson - his last great album was merely to finish a project he abandoned when he was young. Paul McCartney - was never as great a songwriter as when John Lennon was around. Lou Reed - wrote most of his great stuff before he was 30, with the Velvet Underground.

Is songwriting a young man's art? Or is it that people always run out of ideas no matter what? Only a few years ago, when I wrote something good, I'm like, "damn, I never knew I had it in me." Now it's like, "wait, didn't I just write this before? aren't I just piecing together some other stuff that I've done before, and done better?" After your best ideas are out in the open, it just gets more and more difficult.

Sunday, 10 January 2010

Tryout: comeback band.

This was a case of somebody actually coming up to me and asking me if I was interested in helping her out for something. She actually was one of the indie bands in the 90s (when there were much fewer such bands than as now). Now she’s trying to make a comeback, and wanted a music arranger. She thought that I was qualified. I didn’t know. But I said yes anyway just to see what would happen.

She sent me a composition. I was quite “meh” about it. OK, I’m quite ego about my abilities but it’s really not that easy to write a song that’s interesting to listen to. That’s why when you claim to be a songwriter, people are immediately sceptical – it’s one of the most difficult skills to master. I know because I spent years (on and off) trying to figure it out.

She didn’t look like a star. I suppose you could say this about most indie rock people. We were in a studio (directly opposite the road from where I jammed with the post-rock guys). As usual, everybody’s either Chinese or Malay.

The song had an Arabic flavour to it, but I didn’t know much about Arabic music other than the call to prayer. I tried to play stuff. I’m a little sneaky so I usually try to bury my parts in the mix. Keyboards shouldn’t be louder than the guitars anyway. I played something that they said sounded like a horror soundtrack. Like the 2nd tryout, I’m never certain whether I passed the audition.

The last run-through got taped, and unfortunately that’s when I goofed up the most. The drummer left early. Later on, I learnt that he was a Berklee grad and knew the leader of the fusion band. And that he was drumming for some other band that I had never heard of but nevertheless had a really snazzy looking site.

We took the MRT. This was the first time I heard of the term “bouncing”, which means you take the MRT to Marina Bay so that you can get all the empty seats there. The 2 guitarists were taking the train all the way to Woodlands and Jurong East. The guy asked me if I was planning on getting a keyboard soon, I was non-commital. I think I have to do the job.

One thing that disturbed me that night came when they were about to pay up for the studio. The studio had gone through 5 or 6 owners over the last few years, and now, it was owned by a gang of 6 siblings. Apparently they were barely making enough to cover the costs of rental. It made me feel a bit bad because I know of a friend who owned a shophouse. He rented it out to a dance school, and when the dance school did not succeed financially, there were a lot of problems with the tenant, who didn’t (and couldn’t) pay up. You are supposed to pay the rent every month but I knew that the tenant was being bled dry.

It will be the same story everywhere. Creative types are always struggling to make ends meet. It's the cold, soulless work that's really lucrative in life.

I’m actually much less bullish now about my prospects of a musical career. What can I do that will still allow me to balance with my work? At least by trying out with a few bands, I actually have a feel of what the music scene is like. But I'm not doing this full time. I'm actually balancing this against having a job, at least 1 other ECA, and, if I were to go down this path, attempting to find a chick. I don't think I have time for more than 1 band. And it increasingly looks as though that band would be the first band I tried out for (ie the fusion band).

And furthermore, that band might not necessarily allow me to do my own music. (either because they might not ask me to write for them, or because my stuff is not going to fit in with their stuff.) In that case I might as well increase my capabilities of how to make music with my computer.

Monday, 28 December 2009

Tryout - Post Rock

10 years ago, I was a college freshman. I responded to an ad for band members. I wrote that I played piano, I played anything, had perfect pitch, had good hearing. I suppose saying stuff like that is a bit like going on a personals page and saying that you are 36-24-36. It does not guarantee that you are the perfect girlfriend, but people will sit up and take notice.

One Saturday, at the beginning of the month, I responded to a few advertisements for people who were looking for keyboardists. Until now, I am still dealing with the responses. There have been around 8 interested parties, I’m following up with around 4. That’s probably too many for me to handle. But until I meet up with a dead end on all these leads, I won’t need to look for advertisements.

When was it possible for me to do this? I think, as early as beginning 2007, around the time when Shingot was dragging me out to salsa lessons. After a while, I quit, and turned to long distance running instead. 2 half marathons and 1 marathon later, I quit. Just wanted a finisher’s medal. Finally I’m doing something that I always wanted to do since I was a teenager. How did I not know that it was so easy for me to find people to jam with? The opportunity cost is unconscionable.

The only difference between then and now is that since the beginning of 2007, I have written 20-30 songs, ever since I found out how cakewalk could let me record down my stuff.

OK, I have actually played keyboards for around 4 hours today. But not really played, because a lot of it was just gawking at people going around doing their own stuff.

First jamming session was with the band I tried out with last week. I’m still going to follow that leader because I want to see what he can teach me, and I’m also in the company of 3 guys who are even more talented than myself. But I was a little irritated that the leader’s conception of “chim” music was funky time signatures. Not that I should complain, since my last incarnation was named after a funky time signature (it is 7/8 in Spanish).

We ran through 1 or 2 of the leader’s compositions. He brought a laptop, and played his stuff. On one hand his stuff is not too bad even though he’s not as good a composer as I am (I’m not going to brag about this to him anyway, I’m perfectly happy being a sideman for now.) There was a truce between the drummer and the leader, and whereas there were some arguments about who was right or wrong during the 7/8 section he was perfectly OK to go drum along. The way that they played off each other was quite great, and I was just happy to play under the radar.

Later on, he said, I have 15 originals, and we will be playing with them. He intends to gig. And if I can still keep up with them after that, you guys might just find yourselves in a nightclub listening to the 4 of us entertaining you for the evening. He was even talking about performing at jazz festivals overseas. God, no, pls help me…

The leader is also a devout Muslim, and was undergoing voluntary fasting. He was explaining to me that it had to do with some birthday of some prophet or something. How he reconciles this with naming one of his compositions, “Withdr awal Techn ique”, I don’t really understand it.

There were 4 hours between the 2 jamming sessions. Time for a nap, and then dinner.
The second jamming session I had was a tryout for a post-rock band. A lot of bands will tell you which age group they are in in advertisements, so they don’t have generational problems. This was – take away me, and the average age of those people I played with today is around 10 years younger than me.

But they played post rock, and I liked that. In fact, it was such an obscure genre, that I was surprised that Singaporeans were doing this. I also like the fact that now, 10 years later, is when people are starting to catch up to the stuff I was listening to 10 years ago.

I was initially enthusiastic about this, because my point of contact was with a chick 10 years my junior. I got to the studio, and then found myself talking to a young 21 year old drummer. Then I found out that everybody else in the band was male. Well, no problem I guess. But surely less fun than being the only male member of an all-girl’s band. Her name was Kim, and I wonder if important indie bands have bass players named Kim. (Kim Deal from the Pixies, Kim Gordon of Sonic Youth.)

This gig didn’t go down very well. I sense they are unsure about adding a keyboardist to the line-up. Post rock doesn’t have a lot of keyboardist, and the stuff they played didn’t really feature keyboards. Also you could tell things from the length of time it took for any 1 of them to respond to me (1 week). But I always believe that there is an extra room in any band for a musical genius like myself. The band was putting together a composition. I didn’t know what to write because I wasn’t used to writing post-rock.

Some of them had a few smokes after the session. It’s a hazard in this line that you will come across more than your fair share of smokers. I asked if this was the only post-rock band in Singapore. They said that the genre was gaining strength in Singapore, even though it’s always been a marginal scene. One of the guitarists was a stand-in for the regular, and he was in a progressive rock band with Kim as well.

The drummer sounded like he was having a great time bashing his sticks out in the original. He asked if he was going to far, but we all felt it was fine. I talked to him about post-rock, and he told me that he hated the term. Music is music, etc. But that’s what we’re doing in the band, right? Post rock is what we’ve been doing. But we should be free to spearhead in other directions, of course.

Sample conversation in the band. "So, uh, how long you been playing keyboards?" "Since before you were born."

Seems like both the bands have much in common. Both have Malays and Chinese. With 1 exception, the Malays play the guitars and drums, the Chinese play the keyboards and bass. Both have capable guitarists and drummers. Both have members living all over the island, in Woodlands, Bukit Batok, Pasir Ris, Tampines, Thompson Rd.

I have 2 more engagements. One of them is with a former frontwoman of an all girl band who released 1 or 2 albums in the 1990s. She’s thinking of a comeback. We talked over the phone, and she sent me a demo. It’s scary, completely different from what I like. But I just have to do some arrangement for her. It will be a plus if we get our stuff recorded.

Another one is a guy who’s trying to get a band together, and he claims to have written pop songs. That’s the vehicle I have to show my compositions. But how will I balance that against what I’m doing for the other 2? Well, at least I know that I would have freed up a lot of time I used to spend on books. It’s a lot of time.

There are a few immediate tasks to do following the belated start of my music career. 1 – learn how to play jazz on the piano. 2 – learn more about how to use the synthesizer, at least make the demos more professional sounding. 3- learn a rock instrument. What will it be, the bass? The drums?

Well, guys, you know that I don’t really go out and enjoy myself for the heck of it. Everything is work. Even my hobbies are work. They aren’t even hobbies, since if you were to consider that a lot of these things are on my “things to do before you die” list, then it is work. It’s something that has to be done. Even my reading was all on the “things to do” list.

Saturday, 19 December 2009

Tryout - Fusion band

During my 2nd time going to the studio to practice my drums, I found the practicing to have some diminishing returns. Well, I was to find that the “You Can’t Hurry Love” / “Lust For Life” drum pattern was really easy and didn’t really involve the pedals. I found myself being able to do one or two fancy tricks, but still struggling to maintain a steady beat for more than 1 minute at a time. (Well if you have to drum for an 8 minute song then you’re screwed. No “Stairway To Heaven” for you.)

After it was over, the guy behind the counter came and told me that time’s up. Then to my surprise, he gave me an impromptu lesson. Turns out that he’s quite a nifty drummer himself. He taught me a few things:

1. First and last thing about drumming – learn to maintain a steady beat. Nothing much else matters. This is true. Moe Tucker is famous for not doing anything interesting with the drums other than holding a steady beat.
2. Practice with your pedals. You can do this anywhere. His mother used to ask him why he was tapping his feet under the dinner table.
3. Practice your trills with the snare drum. Once you got those basics right, then you can do all your fancy tricks with the other drums.
4. The centre of a cymbal sounds a bit like a cowbell when hit
5. This is not tennis where you have to keep a stiff wrist. Most of the flexibility from drum movements revolves around the wrist. (No wonder Max Weinberg kenna RSI when he was drumming for Bruce Springsteen.)

The other thing is, how do drummers practice in Singapore? The hardest thing when living in a country with no garages is to find a place for drummers to practice. Fortunately he said, just use your pillow. That’s great. So I have an inexpensive way of practicing the drums without blowing $13 per hour.

That week I went on www.soft.com.sg, which is one of the biggest musician’s forums in Singapore. I advertised myself as a keyboard player who has a grade 8 (this is true) who has perfect pitch (true) and who’s a nifty songwriter (also true). I also said that I have 20 years’ experience but that’s misleading – I learnt piano while young, did not very much, and just let 20 years elapse. I have been writing songs on and off for 20 years so I suppose you could count that.

I also looked up advertisements of people looking around for a keyboardist. There weren’t many around. I thought I had better learn how to play the drums or the bass, that way I could have a chance at being in a proper band.

The first tryout was with a guy who, I could tell, was rather proud of his guitar playing skills. He was also giving lessons to people, and I found out that he was a Berklee graduate. (I’m talking about the famous music school, not the famous Bay Area university.) I asked him what sort of stuff to expect to play. Then he gave me the name of 2 Chick Corea and 2 Charlie Parker pieces. I gagged. But I still went out and tried anyway, figuring out that if I screwed it all up (and I believed that I was going to screw it up) at least I took a shot at it.

When I entered the studio, at least it was a familiar area. It was the exact same studio where I twice went down to try out the drum kit. Seated at the drum kit was a portly Malay guy who admitted to having eaten 3 ice creams over the course of 1 afternoon. The guitarist who contacted me was an intense looking Malay, and the bassist was a skinny Chinese whose mannerisms reminded me of Honest Face (so I’ll call him Honest Face 2).

They started out with Chick Corea’s “Spain”. I wasn’t familiar with the chords, and I was desperately trying to keep up, splashing and sinking like a cat in water. The guitarist turned to me and said, “play a solo”, and I couldn’t play. In fact, no matter how much I like jazz, I can’t play it. At least not yet. The second piece was not much better. I was reduced to just playing chords and letting them jam on. Later on the guitarist made it easy for me and played stuff I knew, like “Superstition” and “Autumn Leaves”. Then the guitarist turned to me and said, “play me one of your songs”. I played them the song I wrote for teapot (Maybe I’ll blog about teapot soon) 1 week ago. I didn’t like everything they did to the song, but they caught on and jammed to it. I was a little amazed. Well it’s nice when you hear something you wrote played properly.

Then they moved on to the original compositions. Naturally they aren’t as good as mine, or at least they didn’t perform it properly. I can’t play well but I am after all a really good songwriter.

Incidently, the drummer here knows the nice dude behind the counter who gave me that impromptu drum instruction.

Later on, when we met for prata, I got to know the politics of the band better. The core of the band was the guitarist and the bass player. They knew each other for 10 years, and they were also part of an ensemble that both of them left at the same time. The guitarist was the nominal leader of the pair (and therefore this group). And he was the best musician among us, technically. But I had a premonition about his character when he posted a message on the message board, scolding another electric guitar teacher for undercharging and spoiling the market. Why be so nasty about this in public?

The guitarist was in full flow, gleefully documenting his exit from the Previous Ensemble. They had a simmering tensions with the leader of the group, who had given a radio interview earlier that day, in the afternoon. Then the guitarist complained that the rest of the band didn’t get paid their fair share, and that their previous frontman did not have much stage presence. Eventually, on that night, and in the same prata store where we set, the Previous Ensemble broke up.

After that, I remember that the guitarist talked a few things about jazz, probably assuming that I didn’t know that much about it. In a way, I didn’t know the theory but I have listened enough to have a feel for it. OK, I was willing to let him talk. He said some things that were useful (like how important it was to have a mentor, how important it was to keep on exploring and learning new things) and a lot of things that were not.

Like how he used to have a mentor who was the keyboardist of an R+B singer. Or like how he insinuated himself into a band so successfully that they fired the old guitarist and replaced the incumbent with him instead. Or like how a lot of people from Berklee can’t play very well, or like how he passed the audition to get his Berklee scholarship.

Throughout the whole conversation, the other two were comparatively quiet. It was only after the guitarist left that things started getting really interesting. The drummer was a session musician, and hired to play with them. He was a drumming teacher in real life. He started bitching about the guitar player, being too caught up with himself and his ego. The bass player, honest face 2, didn’t mind the guy that much, but he conceded that there were character defects. Then the drummer complained about the original piece that he wrote, said there was a weird time signature. I had to agree with that. I don’t mind listening to difficult pieces if there’s a soul in there, something worth listening to. What I can’t stand up for are technical difficulty for the sake of technical difficulty. In other words, musical masturbation. Well that guy was dangerously close to being a musical masturbator.

Drummer pointed out that this ensemble was dangerously close to being just a vehicle for guitarist’s superior skills. Which would be pretty annoying. I said that players in the band must think about the bigger picture, and they should think about how the whole band works, rather than just accompanying a virtuoso. We agreed on that much.

But then the drummer said something else I wasn’t sure I agreed with. He said that you had to connect with the audience and play what they want. I always believed in being 1 or 2 steps ahead of the audience. But maybe he was a professional musician and he always believed in that. Whereas me, I’m a person with adventurous tastes, and I go for just about anything except for heavy metal. I’m more of a pushing the boundaries kind of thing. I’m more for that “you follow your heart, and the audience follows you”. But in a way we both agreed that maybe the guitarist wasn’t always following his heart.

Apparently I had passed the audition, but I shudder to think what lies in wait for me. Maybe I did OK, and would do fine just being very unspectacular while he did all the soloing. In the event, Guitar player did ask for my contact thereafter.

All of a sudden, though, 2 more people whose ads I replied to showed up in my email inbox. One of them is a post-rock (think Tortoise, Mogwai) band and another one is a Britpop band. Both look interesting propositions, so I guess there are more tryouts ahead. I think I should remember one thing: I don't know where I came across this saying before, responding to band ads is not like ordering pizza, it's not like you send a private message on a forum, and suddenly a band appears before you for you to audition for. I suppose the band members all have to look at the responses and decide who to talk to.

I suppose I am making a bit of headway now.

You see, I have options. I can either hang around matchmaking web sites, and write to women one by one begging to have dates with them so that I can pay the bills at expensive restaurants, or I can become a rock star and have them line up in front of me for the opportunity to suck my dick. I'd very much prefer the latter.

Wednesday, 9 December 2009

Drums

My sister, who once heard me tap my fingers idly, said that I should learn how to play the drums. I think that I'm finally going to take her up on that suggestion.

10 years ago, when visiting Disneyland, I bought a pair of drumsticks in Orlando hard rock cafe, fully expecting that I would use them one day. I didn't do it.

The student dorm that I was in for my first year in the U was next to a block whose theme was music. They had a jamming studio on the first floor. I had gone down there for a few jamming sessions and that was it. I played the keyboard. The ppl I was with were keen to continue but I decided that I didn't travel halfway around the world just to play some jams. (But if you asked me now what I travelled halfway around the world for, I'd have been hard-pressed to answer you. There's nothing tangible that I could point to.)

When we were young, we had it drummed into our heads that playing music was not a reputable past-time, even though it had already been a tradition in the West, that anyone could start a band, and it was a rite of passage, or at least an attempt at being entrepreneural.

I remember that in the early 90s, there were only a handful of alternative rock bands in Singapore, many of them were heavy metal / hardcore, and I wasn't interested in that at all. I hadn't noticed it very much over the last few years, but the band scene in Singapore had grown a lot. If nothing else, it made it very easy to go looking for band mates.

Any way, I don't think I can handle a guitar, so I would have to look for other people who are good at playing. I can do song writing. It's funny that many song writers out there don't play guitars. Paul McCartney was perfectly happy playing bass (although he played guitar in early versions of the Beatles). Sting played bass. Brian Wilson played bass. Antonio Carlos Jobim didn't play anything. Ian Brown played the tambourine. Stevie Wonder played everything other than the guitar. I'm happy to let other people handle the complicated instruments.

Anyway there are a lot of jamming studios in Singapore. Unfortunately the drums are not something that I would really want in my house right now, firstly because it takes up space, and secondly because it annoys the neighbours (even though I don't have neighbours that I'm afraid of pissing off.) So last weekend I went to a studio, and payed $13 for the privilege of bashing the drums for 1 hour. That is expensive. I wish I could find a cheaper place to practice. But it sure beats shelling up $7 for an expensive cup of coffee, and you have the privilege of doing nothing.

It went OK. At first, my pedalling was so weak, I couldn't even get the bass drum to give me a simple beat. Later, as it went on, I tried to figure out how to do some fancy stuff with the drums. Some of it came off well, others didn't. I was eavesdropping on the neighbours, and the drums sounded funkier than mine. Then there was the hi-hat on the left foot. What does a high hat do? I couldn't co-ordinate 2 hands and 1 leg at the same time, so how on earth was I going to play drums with all 4 limbs at the same time?

Anyway, drummers seem to be a rare commodity in Singapore, judging by the number of advertisements which ask for drummers. I think I really should learn the bass, because drummers are almost never the leaders in rock bands. They could lead jazz combos (think Art Blakey, Buddy Rich) but even then that's rare. OK, there's Lars Urlich from Metallica but that's about it. It's much easier to balance the bass with telling the rest of the band that they're going to play your song, how to play this riff, that riff, etc, how it all fits in together.

Well, that hour passed quite quickly, even though I was trying to be playing the whole time. Sometimes, though, you just have to give your legs a break. It's OK, at least I have 1 more hobby with which to pass my time, so that I can throw out some old hobbies I no longer need. (*cough* basketball *cough*).

So I went on one of Singapore's leading music forum, and advertised myself as a "keyboardist" and a songwriter. I got 3 or 4 replies. We'll see. If I have to play with ppl 10 years younger then so be it.

Saturday, 14 November 2009

Punk

I think a lot has been written about punk. What does it mean? Why is it a movement? I’m not a good anthropologist, but punk is obviously something that I identify with. The punk movement became fashionable in Britain, and some parts of the USA in the late 70s, which was coincidently the time when I was born.

The fact that it exists means that the potential for it has always been there. There are always young people around, and some of them will always be rebellious. But probably it would not have been a worldwide movement until the 60s. That was the time when a privileged generation, the baby boomers was growing up in the West, and for the first time a large enough group of people actually had time on their hands to express rebellious attitudes towards society without being thrown into prison.

In 1968 there was a spontaneous wave of student rebellions all over the world. Many unis in the states had riots or had buildings taken over by students, including the one I went to. There were student protests in Mexico, and it ended up with the students getting fired upon. In Paris, where it ended up with Charles De Gaulle being forced out of power. In Prague, and the Russians ended up having to send in the tanks.

It was bizarre. I don’t really know what they were fighting about, but they were probably like young people everywhere, they thought that the older generation were corrupt and too conservative. They were going to build a better and more idealistic world. Sounds familiar isn’t it? They were protesting the Vietnam War. There were a lot of communist sympathisers. Ho Chih Minh, Mao, Castro and Che Guevara were their heroes.

I supposed that was one of the high points of radical leftist politics, because from the 1970s onwards, America slowly became a more and more conservative place, until you had the age of the Reagans and the Bushes.

Anyway, the way I knew about the punk movement was through music. In the beginning there were a few bands who wrote the blueprint of what punk was about. There was the Velvet Underground, who took a lot of minimalist ideas from modern classical music, and fused it with rock music. They used to be more influential than popular. Now they’re influential and popular. There were bands like the MC5 and the Stooges. They played a very abrasive and loud form of rock music, but it was stripped down and simplified. Iggy Pop is still alive and kicking today, even though Dave Alexander and Ron Asheton are not. He is as indestructible as a cartoon character. A heroin habit did not kill him. The propensity to slash himself over and over on stage did not kill him. Rolling around on broken glass in performances did not kill him. You probably wouldn’t know it by looking at him but he topped his high school.

Thereafter, there was a scene in New York, where bands like Blondie, Television, the Talking Heads (David Byrne performed in Singapore recently), the Ramones and the Patti Smith group developed a more arty form of punk. Punk music briefly became popular in 1977, through the music of the bands Sex Pistols and the Clash. Wire. There was a band in Australia called the Saints. Suddenly everybody was forming a band.

Inevitably (because punks are by nature very self destructive) the punk movement burned out. But even though it faded away from the scene, there were a lot of bands that carried on the tradition. There were Sonic Youth, REM and Husker Du, who were very heavily influenced by punk, and would very heavily influence generations of bands that followed them. There were Black Flag, Minor Threat and the Germs, who would be more faithful to the bare, stark angry ravings of the Sex Pistols.

More crucially, punk mutated into New Wave. The simplicity of punk music inspired many to do likewise: you had Duran Duran, Joy Division and U2. It wasn’t around anymore but it had a huge influence on 80s pop.

Suddenly, in the 90s, it took over the world. Around the time I started following music in a big way, a band called Nirvana took over the number 1 spot on the albums chart from Michael Jackson. For a few years after that, many bands which had toiled in the underground movement start putting out albums on major labels. Thus, you had Soundgarden, Pearl Jam, Mother Love Bone, Screaming Trees following in its wake. The Smashing Pumpkins. Radiohead. Stuff like that.

After that, numbernine grew up and switched to listening to Jazz, and has not concerned himself with matters of the punk world anymore.

Anyway, what characterises punk music? What’s it all about? In 1977, the first time it became popular, it was a rebellion against the idea of a rock star. The rock stars had become fat and lazy. They were too rich and flaunted their wealth too ostentatiously. Their music went down in quality, and their concerts dragged on for too long. So when punk music came along, it was a rude blast of fresh air.

Punk is anger and rebellion. It is simplicity. It is about revolution, railing against whatever happens to be the current system. Punks like to think of themselves as straightforward and true to their ideas, although sometimes I think they’re just confused. They despise folks who carry themselves in a courtly and aristocratic manner. Those people sometimes have to say things they don’t really mean in order to avoid giving offence. Punks dispense with such formalities. Punks are like guerillas, and they live in an austere environment. Punk is the confused teenage years. Punk is about sex, not love, although one punk love song that comes to mind is “Ever Fallen In Love With Someone You Shouldn’t Have” by the Buzzcocks. Even then it is important to note: punks seldom get the girl.

On the good side, they are energetic, and they signal change. When you hear one of the greatest punk bands, the Clash, you will be amazed at how simple and effective their early music is. They can write simple songs like the Beatles, although the Beatles never took their music to such extremes. Later on, Clash would throw all sorts of influences into their music, even though the main thrust was still punk.

I always thought that good punk music is very methodical and disciplined. You are forced to finish saying everything under 3 minutes, and you are only allowed to use 3 chords. (If you are Wire, then you are only allowed to use 1 chord, and your songs are shorter than 1 minute.) And if, in spite of all these self imposed constraints, you can still come up with something worthy, good for you.

On the bad side, they are lazy, good for nothing, irresponsible and blame “society” for the plight they are in. It is no surprise that they came up in a bad economic environment, as the UK found itself in the last few years before Thatcher took over. Bad punk music is repetitive, uninspired and mediocre. They get drunk and take drugs. Punk is about being defeated by the system. Note that the Clash chose to cover “I Fought the Law and the Law Won”.

Bart and Lisa Simpson are a little too different to be siblings, but in a way they represent two faces of youth culture. Bart is a punk, simple as that. Lisa is the idealistic activist. But there are similarities between the two. Deep within the spirit of punk, under that rebelliousness and love of freedom is an idealism that you can shape the world into your own image. After all, the other face of the coin of cynicism is idealism - in order to be that disappointed with the world, you probably had to have pretty high expectations of it in the first place. And lying deep under the idealism, is the realisation that left on its own, the world does not make itself a better place. Part of wanting to shake things up or turn a bad situation around is to stand and rebel against the status quo.

Punk is not for everybody. I have a cousin who’s fairly open minded about music, but he did not understand punk music. I suppose you need to have it in you to identify with the chaos and rage.

I have something of the punk in me, obviously. People are what they are - you can’t change them. If you put them in a school which is very obsessed with its own image and how it presents itself in public, people like me would spend hours plotting how to rebel against that. I spent 10 years being educated in classical music, but it never feels natural to me. Because classical music is the music of the aristocratic class, which I have no affinity for. I appreciate its intricacy and complexity, but I could not appreciate Mozart or Tchaikovsky or Haydn. Beethoven - he’s the nearest to a punk in those days. And I like modern classical music better because they were starting to do all that edgy, shrill, dissonant stuff.

For me to identify myself with many (not all) of these values, I think I have an innate predilection towards being rebellious. It’s OK, I guess. I have 2 halves sharing a tense co-existence with each other: one of them the rigorous geek. The other the punk rebel. Somebody has to be the bad egg. Somebody must have the chip on his shoulder to be critical. Somebody has to be the poison pen. We can’t all be sheep. A good scientist is also a rebel. Think about Noam Chomsky. Albert Einstein. Charles Darwin. OK, Chomsky is a nutcase when he’s not talking about Linguistics, but I still think his heart is in the right place. Everybody must have something to contribute to society. I contribute my middle finger.

I don’t really know why have these personality characteristics. So very unChinese of me. A lot of the more interesting fellars in all those old Chinese stories were the rebels, because if you were brought up in that kind of environment, and still ended up as a rebel, you really had to be crazy.

I’ve always seen my father as a boring accountant. But in the last 10 years he has gotten himself into a fair bit of activism, that has seen him get up the noses of some fairly important people. So I suppose I have had a lot more respect for him.

But it is not straight forward hero worship. He told me he just didn’t have it in him to be a brown noser. He couldn’t be a yes man for a long time. That would be true for me as well. There’s something to clarify - it’s not completely true that I have made the choice to be a rebel. Some things we do well, others we don’t do so well. To a large extent the role that you play in society is not yours to choose, it’s fate. Fate gives you a hand of cards and you just play them the best that you will. In a way, I have a very perverse respect for people who can control their gag reflex and suck up to people. In a way I almost think that they deserve their exalted place in society because it is their reward in a society which rewards that peculiar talent. Just as people think that it is unfair that great talent for being able to control a ball with your feet is so lucrative, it is inevitable that other useless talents are so well rewarded.

Wednesday, 11 November 2009

Kurt Cobain

Timeline:

1980s: Big hair bands ruled the day. Bon Jovi, Warrant, Poison. They were perceived to be more about image than music. During the 1980s, the major labels dominated the music scene.

Late 1980s: An underground scene emerges, formed by people who feel that the original values of rock and roll - teenage rebellion against society, anarchy, revolt against the established order – have been compromised by these large corporations who package rebellion and sell it to the masses.

1991: Kurt Cobain, a brilliant songwriter, forms Nirvana and storms to the top of the charts. He’s the vanguard of the underground scene that delivered a blow to the music industry that they’re still recovering from today, and broke their stranglehold on the upper reaches of the pop charts.

1992-1994: After releasing 3 albums of great music, Kurt Cobain is disenchanted with his heroin addiction, the pressures of fame and fortune. Most of all, he has become the person he hated the most – a rock star. Eventually, he kills himself. One of his last songs is titled “I Hate Myself And I Want To Die”.

2009: Kurt Cobain’s image is appropriated for Guitar Hero 5. He is portrayed as the ultimate rock star. He is singing Bon Jovi. A newspaper commentator remarks that it’s OK “because Kurt Cobain can’t kill himself a second time”. His widow, Courtney Love, hardly the most well liked personality in show business, goes apeshit.

Saturday, 24 October 2009

This is Hardcore

The CD player I bought from totoro 3 years ago has died. It didn't exactly die die. It was always a piece of crap. The CD door just stopped working one day, although it could still play stuff. But I think it was high time to chuck it.

The CD that was stuck inside was one that I don't play very often, but it's an album made about reaching your 30s and feeling that your life is going downhill all the way from now on.



A fairly highly regarded piece of work artistically, but this was a piece of work made under emotional turmoil: Jarvis Cocker had just become famous after more than 10 years of obscurity, but the lifestyle of hobnobbing with the famous (and all the bullshit that went with it) was starting to take its toll: it culminated in this especially infamous incident where he showed his backside to Michael Jackson (ie the moonwalker was mooned):



If your CD player could only play 1 album, it shouldn't be "This is Hardcore" by Pulp. That's bad. Not really something you want on constant rotation. So at the suggestion of the colleague, I took it apart with my screwdriver, and took out the CD. Now that the damn thing is out of my CD player I feel better.

Saturday, 3 October 2009

Law of Large Numbers

I wrote the music when I was running at McRitchie. Night fell and I was groping my way around in the forest for a while.

I wrote the first part of the lyrics while driving. It's my favourite set of lyrics so far. The middle section has no purpose other than to wind up people who don't like maths.

If I had a time machine
to bring me back to yesterday
before I screwed it up,

Would I do it differently
or would I do it all again
because I'm being me?

Who is to say, if I didn't do that yesterday
I wouldn't do the same dumb thing
on another day?

Statistical theory:
the action of an agent is
the realisation of

that which is inherently
a trait deeply embedded in his
personality

Repeated instances of that experiment
will show me screw it up again -
the Law of Large Numbers!

McCartney had it wrong,
There is no going back into
a fabled "yesterday"

Walk on by and don't look back
the things you never get are the
things you never had.

Sunday, 27 September 2009

Beatles - 2

The Girlfriend
Every band has a disruptive influence on their music which is blamed for breaking the band up. But seldom has this influence been encapsulated in 1 person: Yoko Ono. She was Japanese. She was an Avant-Garde artist in her own right, and even if she was not as great an artist as John Lennon was, she had a tremendous force of personality, and was a great influence on him. The Beatles always had girlfriends whom they got along with with various degrees of success, but they were second class citizens, and a lot of the time they played a marginal role in the band. This was until Yoko Ono came along.

Yoko Ono was a polarizing figure. Some admired her for being a feminist pioneer. Opinion is divided about how talented she really was. Some were happy that John had finally found the true love of his life. Others despised her for being a talentless groupie, and – well – Japanese. But after she came along, John Lennon broke the golden rule that girlfriends don’t come to the studio. She started putting in her contribution, most notably to the song “Revolution No 9”. She was an unwanted 5th member of the band, and more significantly, it was clear that after she came along that John Lennon’s heart was no longer in the Beatles. There is no doubt that would have happened anyway with or without Yoko Ono, but she now bears the unwanted tag of being the woman who broke up the Beatles.

There would be other bands that had their Yoko Ono. The most famous one was Nirvana, and Kurt Cobain’s widow, Courtney Love was always called his “Yoko Ono”

Artistic growth
Most bands do not go through the 3 phases of being a lowly pub band, then being teen idols, and lastly being highly respected artists, but since at least 1 of these labels apply to the majority of bands. The Beatles came of age at a time when the rest of pop music was highly experimental and constantly breaking new ground at a rate that has not been matched since. They were innovative in many ways.

Right from the start, they were good musicians and songwriters. But as time went on, they progressed from the teenybopper head shaking “woooo!” songs to write songs of greater depth and sophistry. They wrote about sex, drugs, politics. They blended surrealism into their art. They achieved sound effects in the studio that had never been done before (but then they were one of the very few artists with the clout to work in the studio practically full time, and with an unlimited budget.) And what they didn’t innovate, they co-opted and assimilated. They easily met the challenges of the Beach Boys, the Byrds and Bob Dylan because they were able to work the influences of these people into their own art. Considering that they were only around for 8 years after they released their first recordings, their rate of growth was incredible.

However, many in Singapore would mainly remember the early days. When they started growing long hair and smoking pot, I think it was too outrageous for the conservative society they had here.

It is probably true that all artists need to evolve and cover new ground in order to remain creatively vital. But soon the band members would hanker for greater artistic freedom, which led into…

The Artistic Differences
In the beginning of their heyday, the Beatles were a tight unit. Much tighter than in the Sutcliffe / Best days. Under Brian Epstein, they presented a united front to the public. The songs were all listed down as Lennon-McCartney songs, and to a great extent, that was true. Even though most of the songs were mainly written by 1 of the two, there were very few that didn’t have a contribution by the other one. However they were always photographed together, and they always played music together.

However, from “Revolver” onwards, they started having more separate identities. It was around the time when George Harrison started writing music. The later songs were more obviously either “Lennon songs” (songs about the ego, surrealist and crazy stuff, punkish rebellious ones) or “McCartney songs” (more melodious, more harmonically sophisticated, character portraits, nursery rhymes). By the time of the White Album, it was a pastiche of solo recordings from each of the 4 Beatles. The famous inner sleeve was the first time they were photographed separately. By the time of “Let It Be”, they were hardly talking to each other. They only patched things up for “Abbey Road”, but that was a Paul McCartney dominated album.

How many other bands were like this? One of the most cited reasons for bands breaking up are “artistic differences”, because this is the one where nobody is really to be blamed, whether the excuse is true or not is another matter.

India
It is true that at some point, the band would want to pursue more exotic avenues. The Beatles went to India to study meditation under an Indian guru, but soon got disenchanted with him. John Lennon wrote the sarcastic “Sexy Sadie” to diss him, and at the last moment, was persuaded to change the original title, which was “Maharishi”.

George Harrison was the one who pushed the band to experiment with meditation and Indian culture. His Indian inspired recordings are not the most well regarded parts of the Beatles canon, but it was not a bad thing that the Beatles wrote a lot of good songs about spirituality (and drugs).

After the Beatles, it was a wide practice for a successful pop band to embrace a foreign culture and work it into their music. The Rolling Stones’ “Paint it Black” had Brian Jones on sitar. Jimi Hendrix had Hindu images on his second album. Paul Simon had his African adventures. The Police had their cod reggae. Madonna had her Kabbalah. Although none went so far as Peter Gabriel, who set up a world music consortium. Each of them would be criticized for not being sufficiently authentic and representative of that foreign element, but then again, each of them would be instrumental in bringing that world music to the attention of a wider audience.

Breakup and Death

It was not that clear at that time, but the breaking up of the Beatles was a fantastic career move. The Beatles never stayed together long enough to see their standards go down hill, although this did happen to each of the individual members. Towards the end, John Lennon was the most unhappy of the Beatles, partly because he felt that his position as the lead Beatle as being usurped by Paul McCartney. (But it was his fault that McCartney was always better at dealing with fame, and was the more hardworking one.) He was depressed and suicidal over getting battered for having found the true love of his life. Their business affairs were in a mess, and both John and Paul had different people representing them. Artistically, they grew apart. Their friendship was breaking down. It was the perfect storm in the making.

So the only surprise here was that at first, only one of them wanted to break up. This was understandable because they were still the number 1 band around, and because they were still functioning pretty well as a unit.

Probably no other band managed to mythologise their breakup as well as the Beatles did. Since the Beatles were always in the news, the various reasons for the breakup were well known to the fans. But this is probably the only time a band of their stature broke up at the height of their success. (Only other examples I can think of offhand were the Police and the Smiths, but although they were great bands, they weren’t in the same league as the Beatles.) They never stayed around long enough to be Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, a shadow of their former self, flogging their dead horses over and over again. *cough* Rolling Stones *cough*.

Both John and Paul wrote about their break ups. John Lennon wrote about it on his song, “God”. (“the dream is over / …. And so my friends, we’ll just have to carry on / the dream is over”). Paul McCartney wrote about it on his “Let it Be”.

The lesson to other bands is that you will probably be more fondly remembered if you break up at the height of your powers, and you don’t tarnish your legacy by releasing inferior stuff afterwards. The Beatles did re-record an old, unreleased song, “Free as a Bird”, and it got a pummeling in the press for not living up to the old stuff.

It was the ideal breakup, a wholesale breakup. Not 1 important band member leaving, and the rest heading in a new direction, as was the case with many other bands.

For the 10 years after the end of the Beatles, John and Paul were hardly speaking to each other. Their finances, and the lawsuits ensured that the relations during the 70s were, while not entirely acrimonious, highly fraught with tension. Lennon and McCartney never got a chance to work together again when John Lennon was murdered. It is quite conceivable that if he had lived, they would have collaborated on something. The Beatles often guested on each other’s solo records here and there.

The fact that there was never a Beatles reunion only helped to cement the legacy of the Beatles. It also “helped” that in their solo work, they never accomplished anything as great as when they were the Beatles.

Reason number 4: They wrote the template.
The Beatles were lucky in a way, because their reign of the pop music world took place when pop music was undergoing great changes, in fact, when society itself was undergoing great changes. Pop music at the beginning of the 60s were a bunch of rock and rollers who sang really nerdy, outdated music. By the end of the 60s, it had reached a level of artistic sophistication that hasn’t really made very much progress, even today, 40 years later. Sorry guys, we’re still living in the shadow of the 60s.

The Beatles matched the progression of 60s pop, step by step, and in many instances, were the innovators.

The British Invasion
OK, since this took place a mere 20 years after D Day, this phrase had a resonance it doesn’t have today. But they were the first British pop group to make it big in America, and are probably the main reason why the UK is a main centre of (English) pop music today. They typified many UK bands: emphasis on strong songwriting, catchy music. Urban, working class. Substance is a must, style is optional. Emphasis on simplicity.

They wrote their own songs.
Or more accurately, John Lennon and Paul McCartney wrote most of the Beatles’ Songs. George Harrison was an above average writer (and he wrote a few classics) but he just wasn’t in their league. The Beatles created the expectation that great pop bands should write their own songs. To understand why this is significant, just compare this to Chinese pop music: you have the singer, who concentrates of singing and looking good, and they sing songs written for them by professional writers.

The legacy of this is mixed, because bands that run out of good new material would inevitably go downhill. There were a lot of bands out there who were generally good with their instruments, that would generally benefit from having other people write material for them.

The Studio
One of the innovations during the 60s was the use of the studio as a special instrument for recording effects. This innovation was not unique to the Beatles, and was also associated with others like Jimi Hendrix, the Beach Boys and Phil Spector. But studio tricks made great strides forward under the Beatles, and after them, a lot of other people would be very inventive about creating interesting sound effects for their music.

They created albums
It used to be that albums were just a collection of singles, or they were just there to put 3 or 4 of the current singles in the same place, and padded up with filler. But Sergeant Pepper was the first of what was to be the concept album, where the whole album was a song cycle, or at least all the songs put together would tell a story, the entire album, instead of the song would be the basic unit.

This concept concept would be responsible for both a lot of artistic triumphs, and a lot of pretentious hogwash.

Sex and Drugs
As said before, the 60s were a time of the collective loss of innocence for people living in the West. It was a time of the sexual revolution, which more or less lasted until the emergence of AIDS. People started experimenting with a lot of drugs. Those were the times. The Beatles of course were not responsible for this, but having 4 young and attractive gentlemen in front of a screaming horde of teenage female fans did not

So – the legacy of the Beatles. Now who wants to say that they’re not the greatest band ever?

Saturday, 26 September 2009

Beatles - 1

Since this blog is named after a Beatles song, I think that I should be writing about the Beatles.

I didn’t know that they re-issued all the Beatles’ albums until I was looking through my favourite music online magazine (OK not my favourite, but it’s one of the most complete ones) and found it chock full of Beatles reviews. I’m not surprised at the release date of the re-issues: 9/9/09. Nine was John Lennon’s favourite number. He wrote “Revolution No 9”, which is actually the most atypical Beatles song of them all.

It’s possible that nobody ever dominated an art form the way that the Beatles dominated pop music.
However, not everybody is that crazy about the Beatles. Once, my sister (one snippet of history: we used to quarrel all the time but she became good friends with me when she found out how fantastic my music collection was) asked me, “you know, I like the Beach Boys and the Kinks more than the Beatles. I always had a few songs I really liked. This isn’t true of the Beatles.” OK, fair enough. Then I remember something my school buddy said years ago when we were discussing music: “Why do people worship the Beatles and why do they worship Shakespeare? I don’t see anything really great about those two. People only regard these guys highly because everybody are sheep.” (My friend despised people who followed the crowd and a lot of that rubbed off on me.)

I don’t know about Shakespeare, but I can say this about the Beatles. Both their statements are not wrong. None of my favourite albums are by the Beatles. But I can still understand why they are the greatest pop group of them all.

Reason number 1: they meant something to everybody.

The Beatles may not have written your favourite songs, but they have produced something for every segment of the market you could possibly think of. Teen bopper? (“Please Mr Postman”) Straight forward pop? (“Help!”) Broadway show tunes? (“Til There was You”) Rock and Roll? (“Rock and Roll Music”) Brill Building? (“Baby It’s You”) Folk? (“You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away”) High school reunion music? (“In My Life”) Romantic ballads? (“And I Love Her”) Drug music? (“Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds”) Hard rock? (“Come Together”) Punk? (“Helter Skelter”) Blues? (“Yer Blues”) Surrealism? (“Strawberry Fields Forever”) String Quartet chamber music? (“Eleanor Rigby”) Nursery Rhymes? (“Ob la di, Ob la da”) Funeral music? (“Let it Be”) Acoustic Ballad? (“Blackbird”) Romantic ballads? (“Something”) Heartbreak song? (“Yesterday”)

And not only did they cover a large ground, they often wrote some of the best songs of each genre they were involved with. The Beatles were also the most covered band ever. Apparently there are 1800 versions of “Yesterday” recorded. This is probably a record. In a way, the Beatles were everywhere. In another sense, they are invisible. Most songs are distinctive enough that the identity of an artist is forever associated with the song. For many Beatles songs, there are many instances where anybody could have taken that song and made it their own. Perhaps this is one of their weakness: many of their songs lack the distinctive force of personality of the artist. But it is also a strength, that each song exists in its own right, rather than sounding like a “typical Beatles song”. There are no typical Beatles songs.

Nirvana wrote “I Hate Myself And I Want to Die”. Oasis wrote “Live Forever”. These are 2 of the 90s bands which most consciously take the mantle of the Beatles, although other than having a lot of loud guitars, they have nothing else in common. Frank Sinatra was famously contemptuous of rock music: he covered “Something”. Classical music fans usually turn their noses up at most of pop music, except at the Beatles.

Reason number 2: They were extremely popular
There are only a few names which have completely dominated pop music for a short period of time. Frank Sinatra. Elvis. The Beatles. Michael Jackson. That’s about it. There was 1 week in 1964 when the #5 song, the #4 song, the #3 song, the #2 song and the #1 song were from the Beatles. That is the one and only time it happened in the UK since people kept records.

Reason number 3: They were the typical pop group.
If there is a bible for pop music, it was written by the Beatles. Just as Adam was the archetypal man, the Beatles were the archetypal pop group. Just as many God fearing Christians ask themselves, “what would Jesus do?”, most pop groups ask themselves, “what did the Beatles do?”

Most famous pop groups have their mythology, or famous stories about them. Jimi Hendrix had his setting his guitar on fire, and dying young by choking on his vomit. (The second story has been revised lately: apparently he was murdered.) Cat Stevens had his conversion to Islam. Elvis had his stint in the Army. Sly Stone had his “happy optimistic phase” and his “dark druggy phase” and right in the middle was “Thank You (Fallatinme Be Mice Elf Agin)”. Pink Floyd had their crazy diamond Syd Barrett.

But the Beatles had the greatest and richest mythology of them all. It just seemed that they shared DNA with just so many other bands.

4 personalities
To be sure, there are 2 ways of looking at the Beatles. There were 4 people who were close like brothers (and this is a compelling version, because the individual members of the Beatles never achieved as much artistic success as they did while in the Beatles.) The other way is that it was John Lennon and Paul McCartney, and 2 others. Both versions are equally valid.

What made the Beatles so compelling collectively is that they were all very different people, but they represented molds that many band members who followed in their wake belonged to. There was John, the fiery, sarcastic and arrogant one. There was Paul, the cute one (but underneath that cuteness was a hugely ambitious social climber). There was George, the shy one but the best guitar player of the lot. There was Ringo, who was exceptional because, even though he is quite the solid, dependable drummer, is the least talented of the bunch.

Think about the Smiths: Morrissey is the John Lennon, and Marr is the George. Take That: Robbie Williams is the John, and Gary Barlow is the Paul. U2: Larry Mullen is the Paul, the good looking one. Bono is the John, The Edge is the George, and Adam Clayton Jr is the Ringo. The Police: Stewart Copeland is the John, Sting is the Paul, Andy Summers is the George.

We know that sweet and sour is a great combination. Paul was sweet and John was sour. They needed each other: John was the cutting edge, and Paul was the one who appealed to the masses. Although Paul has a quite an unfair reputation for being a conservative, and the less artistic one, in fact his best songs had an artistic sophistication beyond what John was capable of. But you always could rely on John to come up with a crazy artistic concept. It was quite apparent to both of them right from the beginning that they needed each other.

John Lennon was the id, Paul McCartney was the ego, and George Martin, who was their producer, and who had the best musical background, was the superego. The Beatles were also very interesting because they had a two headed leadership. No one personality dominated the band, so you could see more than one facet of the many-headed monster.

The other two? George was no slouch. He was not a Clapton or a Hendrix, but he could play a mean guitar all the same. He was ambivalent about fame. Ringo Starr bore the fame with equanimity, although they had to deal with less than John and Paul. But they were famous together, they were the Fab Four, so they had to deal with it. And they were all level headed enough to be good at dealing with the pressures of fame. I think they were important because their presence turned the Beatles into a family. The other two more famous ones could always rely on them, until the end. Come to think of it, the big irony of the Beatles is that John Lennon, the first Beatle, and the leader in the beginning, was the one least able to deal with the fame.

They all had their turns at the mike. They also wrote a song about friends that never leave you in spite of your inadequacies, and not surprisingly they let Ringo sing it. The Beatles were a very effective unit because of their contrasting and complementary personalities.

Art School
It has become a truism that bands come from Art School. John Lennon couldn’t fit in anywhere, so he went to Art School. Paul McCartney was good at school, but it all went downhill after he joined the Beatles. It was just as well that they all had a sense of aesthetics: appreciation of beauty is something that is rarely confined to any one art form. This brings us to another great cliché of bands: the ones who were with them at the beginning, but left before they became famous.

The could-have-beens
There were 2 more Beatles: Stu Sutcliffe, and Pete Best. Sutcliffe was John’s art school classmate, and a talented artist in his own right. He imparted a sense of aesthetics to the band, and helped shape their early image, in the style of the Rockers. But he died young. In any case, he wasn’t terribly talented in music, and he plonked along on his bass guitar. He didn’t get along with Paul McCartney, since both of them were vying to be John’s number two. Eventually he knew that he didn’t belong there, and he left the band.
Pete Best was another story. He was a drummer, and the most handsome of the four. He played with them throughout the Hamburg days, but he was sacked, almost on the eve of the Beatles getting popular. No reasons were given, but a few have been suggested: he didn’t fit in, he was too handsome and popular with the girls, and Ringo was simply a better drummer.

Needless to say, the early band members who didn’t make it are part of the rock band tradition.

The pub band
The Beatles paid their dues before getting famous. John Lennon formed his own band in his teenage years, and for a long time, was the only competent member of the band, until he met Paul, and shortly after that, George. It’s another tradition that even the greatest bands have humble beginnings. But that is not always true: there are bands formed by members who were already famous: these bands are called superbands. Examples are Led Zep, Emerson Lake Palmer, and Traffic.

Hamburg
The rite of passage for a band is that they play on the road, overworked and underpaid, while they earn their experience points. Nobody could accuse the Beatles of not paying their dues. They also first became stars of the pub circuit in Hamburg, before making it big back at home in Liverpool, and like so many other bands after them, first made it big overseas before a triumphant homecoming.

Record Company Rejections
Before the internet, and before punk, you had to sign with a major label if you had any hope of making it big. The Decca audition was infamous because they went down to the label, made a few cuts over a few days (some of which were below their best) and the record company listened to them and decided they weren’t good enough, and anyway boy bands were on the way out. This has gone down in history as the biggest mistake ever made by any record company executive.

The Manager
The Beatles had one of the more colourful managers. Brian Epstein was different from the Beatles in so many ways: he was a son of a rich man, Jewish, and gay. He was gay at a time when it was not acceptable to be gay – the gay movement would only come up in the 1970s. He saw them while they were performing in Liverpool and got so turned on that he decided he was going to manage them. He was instrumental to their early success, promoting them as a cute boy band, and shaping their image. However his role became more and more marginal as the Beatles started to grow in other directions.

John Lennon was famously contemptuous of him, and treated him cruelly, although Epstein seemed to enjoy the sadomasochism of it all. When singing his song from “Magical Mystery Tour”, John allegedly sang “Baby you’re a rich fag Jew” instead of “Baby you’re a rich man, you”.

In the end, his behaviour became more and more volatile, and his drug taking spiraled out of control, aided by his anxiety that he was being cut out of the decision making process. He overdosed on drugs and died. His death was a big shock to the band, but in the long run, it resulted in their taking over their own management. They were quite incompetent at managing their affairs, and this was the beginning of the end for the Beatles.

In the wake of their breakup, their affairs were in such a mess that it took years of lawsuits to sort everything up. This state of affairs was the main reason why it took so long to remaster all of the Beatles’ stuff.

Beatlemania
It was crazy, as was said earlier. The enduring image of the Beatles is of 4 guys being mobbed by fans wherever they went, of teenage females going crazy and fainting, of their having to sneak out of back doors to avoid being mobbed by crazy fans. In the middle of their career, they quit playing live for good.

Their relationship with the media evolved, as was the case of many of their peers. The press, in their early days were greatly supportive of the Beatles. But as time went by, they started getting hounded by the media. John Lennon took the brunt of it, for his statement about being “more popular than Jesus”, and for his relationship with Yoko Ono.

Many bands that followed would follow this script: the initial euphoria of fame, giving way to the cracking up under the pressure. The claustrophobic life leading to disenchantment with the high life. The drugs for escape. An initially receptive press that ultimately turns against them.

Friday, 26 June 2009

Wacko Jacko

When I was a kid my parents told me about Michael Jackson, who had just released his "Thriller" album some time back. Of course there was something curious about it that I couldn't put my hand on, but later on I figured out what it was. It was the strange fact that the king of pop was black.

In a way, racism was more or less dead for me, from that day. I was an impressionable kid, but I no longer really believed that a black man was incapable of doing stuff that people of other skin colours were capable of doing.

But I'm still a little disturbed by the way that black artists handle fame and fortune. Bobby Brown - drug addict, and pulled down Whitney Houston with him. Sly Stone - the less said the better. Jimi Hendrix - dead. Tupac - dead. Marvin Gaye - murdered by his father. Notorious BIG - dead. So on one hand, there are no differences between a white man and a black man, but on the other hand, there are important diffences - one swims in a sea of mostly white people, and the other one swims in a sea of mostly black people. If people decide whether or not to screw with you, they see first whether you are black or white. Have they figured out how to become a star? Elvis didn't figure it out, the Beatles didn't quite get it at that time. Maybe the black brothers will, someday.

You couldn't say these weird stuff happened to all child stars. Shirley Temple kept her head. Stevie Wonder - you wonder whether he was ever a kid at all because he seemed to be an adult even when he was young. Some people never got over it, not only MJ, but also Beethoven and Mozart.

I had read J Randy Taraborelli’s biography of Michael Jackson, which I sold on to Nat. (Yes, all 650 pages of it) It’s full of interesting detail, a little tabloid-y, and not a few unsubstantiated stories, but the picture that emerges is consistent and disturbing. There is some real psychological insight to his stories. Because, let's face it, Michael Jackson is seriously one mentally unstable guy. You think his face on the "Thriller" video was scary? Look at his real face 25 years later, without the prosthetic nose. Now that is scary.

One line from his book struck me: Michael saying, “it’s not lying, it’s show business.” This sums up everything you need to know about his (non-existent) ability to distinguish fiction and reality.

The man has so many contradictions that it’s fascinating. On one hand, he’s a ruthless businessman, and one of the very few people who can basically fleece Paul McCartney of his profits. On the other hand, he’s done so much for children’s charities. On one hand, he’s got so much discipline to become a great artist, on the other hand he’s such a conflagrate spender. On one hand, as a newspaper describes him, he seems to have lived so many lives before. On the other hand, he really has had only one life – as an entertainer. No proper childhood, a prospect that would haunt him for the rest of his life.

You probably heard about the rumours concerning him living in an oxygen tank. That was actually a stunt that he engineered himself. He thought it would be quite funny to print some bizarre stories about himself. There was no truth to it. But the damage done ultimately was considerable – he started getting known as Wacko Jacko, and the breakdown in trust between him and the media started a cottage industry whereby anything strange he did would be amplified into real weirdness.

There were some funny stories in there, like the time when he got arrested by the LAPD, and they spent 1 day trying to open a huge bank vault in his mansion. When they did, there was only a suitcase containing the combination to the safe.

But there were also stories of his real humiliation, for example how they took of his pants and tried to identify the marks on his dick.

The thing about stardom is that it brings you into the gaze of the entire world while almost completely cutting off contact between oneself and the real world. He almost alienated everybody who worked with him. Lisa Marie Presley, with whom he had a real relationship, and the person who knows both Kings of Pop first hand. Debbie Rowe. Even Elizabeth Taylor. There was a very astute businessman who helped him obtain very lucrative deals, he got cut off too, and to me that was the start of his financial downfall.

He never learnt from his lesson. He was such a strong willed person that nobody could tell him the truth, or to scold him (except maybe Lisa Marie Presley, but in the end she gave up). He still conducted the pajama parties with the kids. He kept on making himself liable to lawsuits. He didn’t understand that it was all wrong, regardless of whether he was really molesting them or not.

Michael Jackson became similar in many ways to the only other person who is routinely called the king of pop, Elvis Presley. Elvis lived in Graceland, Michael Jackson in Neverland. Both became drug addicts – Elvis to pills, Michael Jackson to painkillers. Both ended their lives a recluses, holed up in their hiding places, surrounded by syncopants.

The concluding sentence of that book rings true: you have to wonder how it was that a person who overcame such great odds to achieve such success was unhappy, and you wondered what he must do to achieve happiness in his life.

When I watched the top of the pops for the first time, Michael Jackson was #2, and the Police was #1. The Police are now touring around the world, selling out shows and making plenty of money. That is what Michael Jackson should have become. But even as we mourn his tragic death, we might remember that this could have been the path that he would go down if he had not succumbed to a heart attack.

Don't blame it on the sunshine, don't blame it on the moonlight, don't blame it on the good times, just blame it on the boogie.

Elvis Presley

Michael Jackson

King of Pop

King of Pop

Popularised black music

The first (and possibly last) black superstar

Mawkish socially conscious songs like “In the Ghetto”

Mawkish socially conscious songs like “Heal the World”

Ushered in the age of Rock and Roll

Ushered in the age of MTV

Married Priscilla Presley

Married Lisa Marie Presley

Branched out into cheesy movies like “Blue Hawaii”

Branched out into spectacular long videos like “Thriller” and “Smooth Criminal”

Famous for sexually aggressive dance moves (like swiveling his groin)

Famous for sexually aggressive dance moves (like touching his crotch)

Famous for sequined Las Vegas jacket

Famous for sequined glove

Startling physical transformation between youth and middle age

Shocking physical transformation between youth and middle age

Lived his later years as a recluse in Graceland …

Lived his later years as a recluse in Neverland …

Addicted to pills …

Addicted to painkillers …

Died young (42) of health problems

Died young (50) of health problems